Lifting the corporate veil: essential keys established by the SCJN in 2026
Lifting the corporate veil: essential keys established by the SCJN in 2026
The issue of piercing the corporate veil has returned to the forefront of business debate following a significant ruling by the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation. Specifically, on September 30, 2026, the Court ruled on direct appeal 57/2025, stemming from litigation between the La Cruz Azul Cooperative and the civil society organization Desarrolladora Táctica FA. In this case, the Court denied the cooperative's appeal and upheld a previous ruling that exempts it from paying approximately 1.584 billion pesos in legal fees. Furthermore, the order to return nearly 647 million pesos that had already been paid remained in effect.
For any company, the ruling offers two lessons. First, being a partner is not enough to be personally liable for the company's debts. Second, someone who signs without authorization is not protected, even if the invoices are subsequently paid.
What did the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation (SCJN) decide in the Cruz Azul case?
The case reached the Supreme Court due to its importance and significance, after several years of litigation between the two parties. According to public information about the case, Desarrolladora Táctica was claiming payment of fees stemming from a legal services contract signed on behalf of the cooperative. Cruz Azul, for its part, maintained that the individuals who signed the contract did not have sufficient authority to bind the cooperative.
Minister Arístides Rodrigo Guerrero García's project was approved unanimously. Consequently, the Court denied the injunction and upheld the ruling in favor of the cooperative.
Key facts of the direct appeal 57/2025
- Body: Plenary of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation.
- Fecha de resolución: 30 de septiembre de 2026.
- Vote: unanimous, with the project of Minister Guerrero García.
- Result: protection denied to Desarrolladora Táctica FA, S.C.
- Amounts: fees claimed for approximately 1,584 million and refund of approximately 647 million pesos.
The two central criteria of the ruling
According to reports from specialized media, the Plenary held two ideas that are of interest to any company:
- The conduct of the parties during the execution of a contract cannot remedy the lack of powers of representation of the person who signed it.
- Likewise, lifting the corporate veil is an exceptional measure, which is only appropriate when there is evidence of an abusive use of legal personality.
During the discussion, Minister Giovanni Azael Figueroa Mejía stated that the case file contained sufficient evidence of the misuse of corporate structures. He also highlighted the effective control that one partner exercised over the companies involved.
Why does this case matter beyond football?
Although the litigation involves a well-known institution, the legal framework is not limited to it. Any company that contracts services, signs agreements, or receives payments can face a similar situation. Therefore, it is important to understand what this legal concept means and under what circumstances it applies. This analysis is intended for partners, board members, legal directors, and suppliers who contract with legal entities of any size.
What is the lifting of the corporate veil and why is it exceptional?
A commercial company registered in the Public Registry of Commerce has its own legal personality, distinct from that of its shareholders. This is established in Article 2 of the General Law of Commercial Companies. Thanks to this separation, the company's assets are liable for its debts, and, in principle, the shareholders' assets are protected.
EXTERNAL LINK: Ley General de Sociedades Mercantiles → https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/pdf/LGSM.pdf
This protection forms the basis of the Mexican business system. Otherwise, few people would invest in a business, because any debt could affect their home or savings. However, the law does not protect those who use a company as a shield to defraud their creditors.
The “curtain” that the Court can draw
Piercing the corporate veil is the tool a judge uses to examine what happens behind the scenes. In other words, it allows them to stop treating the company as a separate entity and attribute its obligations to the person who actually controls it. It is, therefore, an exception to the general rule of asset segregation.
The Court insisted that this is an extraordinary measure. It is not enough to demonstrate that someone is the majority shareholder or controls the administration. Nor is it sufficient that the company has debts it cannot pay.
What the criterion does require
For this to apply, an abuse of legal personality must be proven. For example, forming companies to evade obligations, defraud the law, or harm third parties. In the case at hand, the Court found independent evidence of this abuse, such as a private agreement contained in a public instrument.
| Is your company facing a claim that could affect the assets of its partners? The lawyers at Baráibar Temblador y Asociados in Mexico City can review your case. Schedule your consultation today. |
The powers of representation: the other major criterion of the ruling
The second message of the ruling is just as important as the first. A legal entity is only bound through those who have the power to represent it. In commercial companies, Article 10 of the General Law of Commercial Companies assigns this representation to the administrator or the board of directors.
In the case of a cooperative, representation corresponds to the bodies and agents designated in its bylaws and the General Law of Cooperative Societies. If the signatory does not have these powers, the contract is not binding on the legal entity.
Paying does not equate to ratification
Many companies believe that if they have already paid part of a contract, that payment automatically "validates" what was signed. According to the reported ruling, the Court rejected that interpretation. The conduct of the parties during the execution of the contract may demonstrate that a commercial relationship existed; however, it does not remedy the lack of authority of the person who signed it.
Article 1802 of the Federal Civil Code stipulates that contracts entered into on behalf of another by someone who is not their legal representative are void unless ratified by the represented party. Therefore, the ratification must come from the authorized body and comply with the necessary formalities.
EXTERNAL LINK: Código Civil Federal → https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/pdf/CCF.pdf
How to verify a power of attorney before signing it?
Reviewing your counterpart's power of attorney takes only a few minutes and can prevent a multimillion-dollar lawsuit. First, confirm that the power of attorney is a notarized document and is currently valid. Second, review the type of powers it grants: Article 2554 of the Federal Civil Code distinguishes between powers of attorney for litigation and collections, for administrative acts, and for acts of ownership.
Additionally, check if the power of attorney has any limits on amount, subject matter, or term. If the contract involves signing promissory notes or other negotiable instruments, Article 9 of the General Law of Negotiable Instruments and Credit Transactions requires specific powers for this purpose. Finally, request a certified copy and keep it along with the signed contract.
The practical effect: to return the money collected
In this case, the consequence was twofold. The cooperative was released from the payment claimed, and, in turn, the plaintiff company was obligated to return what it had already received. Thus, anyone contracting with a legal entity should verify the counterparty's legal standing before signing, not after. According to Jorge Arriaga Chan Temblador, Managing Partner of Civil, Commercial and Labor Lawsuits at Baráibar Temblador y Asociados, “in commercial litigation we frequently see multimillion-dollar contracts signed by people without sufficient power; reviewing the power of attorney before signing costs much less than litigating afterward.”
When is the lifting of the corporate veil appropriate according to the Court?
The 2026 ruling follows a line of reasoning that Mexican courts have gradually developed over the years. Based on reports about the ruling, several scenarios can be identified in which a judge could lift the veil:
- Fraud against the law: the company is used to circumvent a rule that would otherwise be applicable.
- Evasion of obligations: companies are set up so that assets remain beyond the reach of creditors.
- Harm to third parties: the corporate structure is designed to harm those who contract with it.
- Commingling of assets: the controlling partner disposes of the company's resources as if they were his own.
The role of the test
In all cases, the burden of proving abuse rests with the alleging party. Likewise, the evidence must be independent of the individual's status as a partner. Documents, bank transfers, private agreements, and the relationship between the companies are typically the elements that a judge considers most carefully.
What is not enough
Owning a majority of shares does not automatically make a person liable for debts. Nor is it enough that several companies share a registered address, directors, or suppliers. Piercing the corporate veil requires demonstrating that the structure was used abusively, not merely that it exists.
Corporate veil and joint and several tax liability: two distinct concepts
It is important not to confuse piercing the corporate veil with the joint and several liability provided for in the Federal Tax Code. They are different institutions, with their own requirements and consequences.
Joint and several liability of partners before the SAT
Article 26, section X, of the Federal Tax Code allows the tax authority to collect certain taxes from partners or shareholders of the company. However, this liability only applies in specific cases, such as when the company fails to register with the Federal Taxpayer Registry or changes its address without notifying the authorities. Furthermore, the amount that can be collected is limited by the partner's share in the company's capital.
Why does it matter to distinguish between them?
The corporate veil is an exceptional legal construct, primarily discussed in civil and commercial litigation. In contrast, joint and several tax liability is expressly regulated by law and determined by the tax authorities. Consequently, a company may be at risk under one provision but not the other, so it's advisable to review both with your advisor.
INTERNAL LINK: obligaciones de las empresas ante el buzón tributario → https://baraibar.com.mx/buzon-tributario-obligatorio-2026-sat-mexico/
Risks for partners, administrators and agents
The failure sends different signals depending on your role within a company. It's advisable to review them one by one, as each role faces different risks.
If you are a partner or shareholder
Your personal assets remain protected by the general rule of separation of property. However, this protection is weakened if you mix your personal assets with those of the company or if you use the company for purposes unrelated to its stated objectives. In such cases, a creditor could request the piercing of the corporate veil to access your personal assets.
If you are an administrator or director
Your primary responsibility is to act within your authority and the company's purpose. Signing contracts that exceed your powers may release the company from obligations, but it can also lead to claims against you. Similarly, the board of directors must ensure that authorized representatives do not bind the company without authorization.
If you are a supplier or service provider
This is probably the highest risk. If the contract was signed by someone without the proper authority, you could lose the payment and even have to return the money already received. Therefore, before initiating any significant business relationship, it's advisable to request a valid power of attorney from the person who will be signing.
INTERNAL LINK: creditor opposition in business mergers → https://baraibar.com.mx/oposicion-de-acreedores-en-fusiones-empresariales/
| Don't face a lawsuit for shareholder liability or lack of authority alone. At Baráibar Temblador y Asociados, we have specialists in corporate law and commercial litigation, ready to defend your interests in Mexico City. |
How to protect your company against piercing the corporate veil?
The best defense is sound corporate practice. These measures reduce the risk of a judge deeming your company's structure abusive:
- Keep the company's bank accounts and the partners' accounts separate.
- It documents in minutes the relevant decisions of assemblies and councils.
- It formalizes in writing and at market value the transactions between companies within the same group.
- Check that the company's stated purpose covers the activities that the company actually performs.
- It grants specific powers, with clear limits on amount and subject matter.
- Verify the capabilities of your counterparty before signing important contracts.
Order in the corporate books
The minutes books, shareholder register, and registrations with the Public Registry of Commerce are your first piece of evidence. If they are up-to-date, it will be more difficult to argue that the company is merely a front. Similarly, well-organized accounting demonstrates that the company has a legitimate business.
Special attention to business groups
When one person controls multiple companies, the risk increases considerably. The Court paid particular attention to the effective control a partner exercised over different businesses. Therefore, corporate groups must justify, with business reasons, why they operate through multiple entities.
What comes next after the Supreme Court's ruling?
The ruling in direct amparo case 57/2025 strengthens two principles that coexist in Mexican law. First, the patrimonial autonomy of corporations, which provides certainty to shareholders and investors. Second, the possibility of lifting that protection when someone abuses it.
A criterion for litigation and for prevention
For the plaintiff, the ruling confirms that piercing the corporate veil is possible, although it requires solid evidence. For the defendant, however, it serves as a reminder that mere status as a shareholder does not justify a personal conviction.
How could this precedent be invoked in other trials?
Litigants can now raise this issue in their claims and responses. Those seeking to pierce the corporate veil will have to provide concrete evidence of abuse, such as bank statements, contracts between related companies, or minutes demonstrating the shareholder's effective control. Conversely, those defending themselves may argue that mere shareholding does not establish personal liability. In both cases, the quality of the documentary evidence will be decisive for the outcome of the trial.
Review your current contracts
If your company has important contracts signed by proxies, it's worth reviewing them today. Confirm that the signatory had sufficient authority and that the power of attorney was valid. If not, you can still rectify the situation through formal ratification by the authorized body.
| Protect your company's assets and those of its partners with expert legal advice from Baráibar Temblador y Asociados. A timely corporate assessment prevents costly litigation. |
Conclusion: clear separation of assets
Piercing the corporate veil remains an exceptional measure in Mexico. With its 2026 ruling, the Supreme Court clarified that being a partner or controlling a company is not sufficient to make one liable for its debts. At the same time, it reiterated that subsequent conduct does not rectify a contract signed without proper authorization. In short, the lesson is the same for partners, administrators, and suppliers: corporate order, clear powers of attorney, and prior verification of the other party.
Frequently asked questions
What is lifting the corporate veil?
This is an exceptional measure whereby a judge ceases to treat a company as a separate entity and assigns its obligations to its controlling party. It is applicable when there is proof of abuse of legal personality, as recognized in Article 2 of the General Law of Commercial Companies, for example, to defraud the law or harm third parties.
Does being the majority shareholder make me responsible for the company's debts?
Not on its own. The general rule is the separation of assets between the company and its partners. According to the reported precedent of direct appeal 57/2025, the Court required independent evidence of abuse of legal personality, such as commingling of assets or the creation of companies to evade obligations, before attributing personal liability.
What happens if a contract was signed by someone without the authority to do so?
Article 1802 of the Federal Civil Code stipulates that a contract entered into on behalf of another without being their legal representative is void, unless ratified. According to reports, the Court held that the conduct of the parties during the contract's execution does not remedy this lack of power of representation.
If the company has already paid part of the contract, is it validated?
Not necessarily. In the Cruz Azul case, the Court upheld a ruling ordering the return of payments already made, because the payments did not remedy the lack of authority. Ratification must come from the authorized body of the legal entity and comply with applicable legal and statutory formalities.
Who legally represents a commercial company?
Pursuant to Article 10 of the General Law of Commercial Companies, representation corresponds to the administrator or board of directors, who may carry out the operations inherent to the corporate purpose. Attorneys-in-fact with formally granted powers may also act, within the limits of amount and subject matter specified in each power of attorney.
How can I protect my assets as a partner?
Keep company and personal accounts separate, document decisions in minutes, conduct intercompany transactions within the group in writing and at market value, and keep corporate books up to date. These practices help demonstrate that the company has an independent legal existence in accordance with Article 2 of the General Law of Commercial Companies.
Legal references
- Ley General de Sociedades Mercantiles, artículos 2 y 10. Cámara de Diputados: https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/pdf/LGSM.pdf
- Código Civil Federal, artículo 1802. Cámara de Diputados: https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/pdf/CCF.pdf
- General Law of Cooperative Societies.
- SCJN, Pleno. Amparo directo 57/2025, resuelto el 30 de septiembre de 2026 (ponente: Ministro Arístides Rodrigo Guerrero García).
- El Contribuyente, “SCJN: ser socio no basta para responder por las deudas” (6 de octubre de 2026): https://www.elcontribuyente.mx/2026/10/scjn-ser-socio-no-basta-para-responder-por-las-deudas/
- El CEO, “Cruz Azul gana otro round en la SCJN” (30 de septiembre de 2026): https://elceo.com/negocios/cruz-azul-gana-otro-round-en-la-scjn-ante-empresa-ligada-a-angel-junquera-libra-pago-de-1500-mdp/
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute formal legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.





