follow us

Contact us:

(+52) 55 5129 4440

(+52) 33 2323 3085

Providencias precautorias en juicio oral mercantil

Precautionary measures in oral commercial proceedings

Precautionary measures in oral commercial trials now have a clear rule regarding how they can be challenged. In March 2026, the Supreme Court, sitting en banc, resolved the Contradiction of Criteria 272/2025. Its conclusion is straightforward: no appeal is admissible against the decision granting or denying one of these measures. Therefore, those litigating in oral proceedings can file for indirect amparo (a constitutional remedy) without exhausting any other legal recourse. This article explains what has changed and how to adjust your strategy.

What did the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation (SCJN) decide regarding precautionary measures in oral commercial trials?

The conflict between two criteria

The Contradiction of Criteria 272/2025 arose from a genuine disagreement between two judicial bodies. The First Collegiate Court for Civil Matters of the Sixteenth Circuit held that these rulings are not subject to appeal. Meanwhile, the Regional Plenary for Administrative and Civil Matters of the Central-Southern Region defended the opposite position. According to that regional plenary, an appeal was indeed admissible.

This difference regarding precautionary measures in commercial oral proceedings was not a mere technicality. In practice, each position forced litigants to choose a different path, risking dismissal if they made a mistake. Furthermore, the uncertainty affected companies that needed to secure assets or prevent their rapid seizure. For this reason, the Court decided to establish a single criterion.

The response from the Plenary

The full court determined that rulings on precautionary measures issued in oral commercial proceedings are not subject to ordinary appeal. Consequently, there is no appeal that must be exhausted before filing for indirect amparo (constitutional protection). The ruling essentially states that no appeal is admissible against decisions granting or denying these measures.

It is worth noting that the Court ordered the publication of this ruling as binding precedent. Once published, it will be binding on commercial judges and courts. In the meantime, it is advisable to check the record in the Judicial Weekly of the Federation before citing it in any legal document.

What did the Court not resolve?

The decision does not analyze whether a specific order was properly or improperly granted. Nor does it replace the requirements established by the Commercial Code for issuing such an order. It merely defines the available legal recourse, that is, the correct procedural route. Therefore, the merits of each measure continue to depend on the evidence, the urgency of the situation, and the guarantee offered.

Who benefits from the criterion?

Creditors, debtors, legal directors, and law firms litigating in oral proceedings all benefit from a uniform rule. Creditors know that a denial of a measure can be challenged through an appeal. For debtors, the message is that they shouldn't wait for an appeal that will never come. Legal teams can standardize their internal formats and schedules. This uniformity saves costs and reduces disputes about the correct procedure, which often take months.

Judges at first instance also gain certainty, as they now know how their rulings will be reviewed. The review process for amparo (constitutional protection) requires them to more carefully substantiate the risk of irreparable harm and the appearance of a valid claim. A well-reasoned ruling better withstands scrutiny by the federal court.

What are precautionary measures and what purpose do they serve?

Concept and purpose

In simple terms, a precautionary measure is a legal action designed to secure a right while litigation is being resolved. The Commercial Code regulates these measures starting with Article 1168, which includes provisions such as the detention of a person and the seizure of assets. Their purpose is to prevent the debtor from concealing assets or leaving the jurisdiction of the court. They also protect the creditor against potential changes in circumstances.

Precautionary measures in commercial oral proceedings are requested before the lawsuit is filed or during the proceedings. The party requesting them must demonstrate, with sufficient evidence, that a real risk exists. Likewise, the judge may require a guarantee to cover any damages caused by the measure if it is later revoked. In other words, the system seeks a balance between speed and protection of the defendant.

Why do they matter in oral administration?

Commercial oral proceedings were designed to resolve disputes swiftly, and precautionary measures within these proceedings are among their most delicate components. Hearings concentrate the debate and the presentation of evidence. However, this speed comes at a cost: the margin for correcting errors is smaller. Therefore, an improperly issued precautionary measure can freeze bank accounts, inventories, or real estate for months.

For a company, the effect is immediate. Seizing assets can halt payments to suppliers, payroll, or outstanding loans. Conversely, for a creditor, an unfounded denial can leave their collection unprotected. It's worth noting, then, that the manner of challenging a decision is just as important as the substance of the claim.

CALL TO ACTION: Do you have questions about this topic? The lawyers at Baráibar Temblador y Asociados in Mexico City can advise you on precautionary measures and commercial lawsuits. Schedule your consultation today.

The procedural dilemma: appeal or protection?

Reloj de oficina con quince marcas resaltadas que representan el plazo para promover amparo

The general rule of the oral trial

Article 1390 Bis of the Commercial Code establishes that no ordinary appeal is permitted against rulings issued in oral commercial proceedings. This rule aims to prevent delays. Therefore, most of the judge's decisions are only reviewed at the end, along with the final judgment.

The problem arose with precautionary measures in oral commercial trials. Other provisions of the Commercial Code allowed for appeals of certain rulings with immediate processing. On the other hand, the general rule of oral trials closed that door. Consequently, some courts applied the appeal process and others did not.

Why does making a mistake cost so much?

Choosing the wrong legal recourse could have serious consequences. If the litigant appealed and the avenue was not available, they lost valuable time. And if they sought amparo (a constitutional remedy) without exhausting an available appeal, the judge would dismiss it as inadmissible. Furthermore, the deadlines for filing for amparo are short.

Article 17 of the Amparo Law establishes a general rule of fifteen days for filing a lawsuit against acts of authority. For this reason, every day lost in a futile appeal reduced the affected party's options. Finally, the conflicting legal interpretations put an end to this uncertainty.

Why did the Plenary reject the appeal?

Speed, orality and procedural economy

The Court's reasoning regarding precautionary measures in oral commercial trials stems from the nature of oral proceedings. This procedure was designed to be swift, oral, and procedurally efficient. Allowing intermediate appeals would make it slower and more complex. In other words, it would undermine the purpose for which the legislature created this avenue.

Furthermore, the Court conducted a systematic reading of the Commercial Code. It analyzed the rules on appeals and those governing precautionary measures. Ultimately, it concluded that the prohibition in Article 1390 Bis also applies to these determinations. However, this conclusion does not leave the affected party without recourse.

The path that remains open

Since there is no ordinary remedy, the affected party can file for indirect amparo without first exhausting other legal avenues. The Amparo Law allows for challenging actions within a legal proceeding when their effects are irreparable. A ruling that affects property or freedom of movement falls close to this scenario. Therefore, amparo becomes the natural recourse.

However, this doesn't mean that everything will be resolved through legal protection. Each case requires proof of the specific harm suffered and timely filing of the claim. First, the challenged action must be precisely identified. Then, it's advisable to offer evidence demonstrating the current harm.

How does procedural strategy change in oral commercial trials?

Diagrama de un edificio con la escalera interior tachada y la escalera exterior resaltada como única salida

For whom is the measure being requested?

A creditor requesting precautionary measures in a commercial oral proceeding must prepare the case file from the very first filing. The request requires data, documents, and a clear explanation of the risk. Otherwise, a denial can only be challenged through an appeal, which is a more technical process. Therefore, it is advisable to invest in a solid request from the outset.

Evidence that should be gathered

The party requesting the measure gathers contracts, invoices, collection emails, and bank statements that demonstrate the debt. Conversely, the party opposing it gathers documents that show the normal operation of their business and the harm caused by the seizure. Both parties must organize the evidence by date and relevance, because the injunction is decided based on what is contained in the file. A disorganized file weakens even the strongest argument.

The guarantee as a key element

It is also advisable to provide collateral in advance. A reasonable amount, backed by an insurance policy or a deposit, increases the likelihood of obtaining the measure. It also helps demonstrate that the applicant assumes responsibility for the consequences of their request. Conversely, a request without collateral typically faces greater resistance.

Who will benefit from this measure?

A defendant affected by precautionary measures in a commercial oral trial must act swiftly. First, they should review whether the ruling is well-founded and justified. Then, they should assess whether irreparable harm exists. Finally, they should decide whether to file for amparo (constitutional protection) or if it will suffice to request the judge to lift the measure with a counter-guarantee.

A common mistake is waiting for the court ruling. Meanwhile, the measure continues to have an impact. For this reason, the analysis should begin on the same day as the notification. Likewise, it is advisable to gather bank statements, contracts, and payroll records that demonstrate the impact.

CALL TO ACTION: Don't face this process alone. At Baráibar Temblador y Asociados, we have specialists in commercial law and corporate litigation ready to defend your interests in Mexico City.

A typical case: from insurance to protection

The stage

Imagine a distributor filing a lawsuit against a client who has defaulted on invoices totaling several million pesos. Before the hearing, the distributor requests the freezing of the client's bank accounts. The judge grants the measure with a brief ruling that barely explains the alleged risk. The next day, the client discovers they cannot pay their employees or cover their main suppliers. This is a hypothetical example, but it reflects what many companies experience when such measures are imposed without prior notice.

The client's lawyer reviews the case file and identifies three problems. The ruling fails to explain why there is a risk of the assets being lost. The guarantee amount is significantly lower than the potential damages. And the insured amount clearly exceeds the amount claimed in the lawsuit. Based on the Court's ruling, the lawyer doesn't waste time on a non-existent appeal and immediately prepares the indirect amparo claim.

La ruta de defensa

The petition for amparo (constitutional protection) must precisely identify the challenged act, which is the resolution that granted the seizure. It must also describe the specific damages with supporting documentation: bank statements, contracts with suppliers, and pay stubs. While the petition is being processed, the client can request a stay of the act to mitigate the immediate impact of the measure. Simultaneously, their attorney proposes an alternative guarantee to the presiding judge that would allow for the release of some of the funds.

The distributor, for its part, defends the measure with evidence proving the debt and the risk of insolvency. Both parties are now litigating on two fronts: the injunction and the commercial trial. Whoever is better prepared on each front will have the advantage. The case demonstrates why precautionary measures in oral commercial trials require swift decisions, well-organized evidence, and coordination between the legal and financial teams.

What should companies, creditors, and debtors do?

Practical list for the legal field

Legal departments can turn this criterion into an internal protocol. First, record the notification date of any ruling and calculate the fifteen-day period. Second, prepare an impact assessment with real figures. Third, define who authorizes the injunction and with what budget.

In addition, review contracts with guarantee clauses. Some require notification to partners or financiers when a measure is taken. For example, a bank loan may be declared in default if a significant asset is seized. Consequently, the response must be coordinated with treasury and finance.

When is it advisable to negotiate?

Not every conflict requires litigation to the end. Sometimes, offering an alternative guarantee resolves the matter in a few days. Similarly, an agreement with a payment schedule can render the measure moot. For their part, creditors also benefit by gaining certainty about receiving payment.

It's important to note that negotiation does not replace a formal defense. It's advisable to file for legal protection in a timely manner while negotiations are underway. This allows the company to retain its rights and maintain legitimate pressure. However, every decision must be documented in writing.

Common errors with precautionary measures in commercial oral proceedings

Four recurring stumbles

The first mistake is confusing the general rule with the exception. Some lawyers continue to file appeals out of habit, even though the Court has already closed that avenue. The second mistake is ignoring the time limits for filing an injunction. A third problem arises when a measure is challenged without proof of actual harm. Finally, many forget that the guarantee can change the course of the case.

Another common pitfall is conflating oral proceedings with ordinary trials. Although both are commercial matters, they follow different rules. Therefore, before taking any action, it's essential to confirm the procedure for the main trial. If the procedure is ordinary, the analysis may change.

How to avoid waste?

The best prevention is to review the current criteria on precautionary measures in commercial oral proceedings each time an appeal is prepared. The courts update their rulings and publish new precedents frequently. Therefore, a quick consultation of the Judicial Weekly Bulletin avoids surprises. Furthermore, a specialized lawyer can identify nuances that a summary might not reveal.

It also helps to maintain a file of sample documents for each scenario. With it, the team can react in hours, not days. In contrast, improvising under pressure increases errors. Therefore, prior preparation is a competitive advantage.

CALL TO ACTION: Protect your rights with expert legal advice from Baráibar Temblador y Asociados. Our team can review your case and propose the best legal course of action.

Conclusion: a clearer way to litigate quickly

The Contradiction of Criteria 272/2025 provides a practical message for commercial litigation. Appeals against precautionary measures in oral commercial trials are not permitted, and indirect amparo (constitutional protection) is available without exhausting other remedies. This clarity reduces the risk of dismissals and expedites the defense.

One final piece of advice for legal departments and law firms: document every decision regarding precautionary measures in commercial oral proceedings, including dates, responsible parties, and reasons. This record helps explain to management why the injunction, negotiation, or counter-guarantee was chosen. It also facilitates the defense if the matter is reviewed by a collegiate court, where the clarity of the case file carries significant weight.

However, the rule does not eliminate the need for a careful strategy. Timeframes remain tight, and proof of damage remains essential. Consequently, companies and creditors would be wise to review their protocols and consult with specialists before taking any action. Early preparation makes the difference between protecting assets and losing them.

Article links

EXTERNAL LINK: Código de Comercio vigente (Cámara de Diputados) → https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/pdf/CCom.pdf

EXTERNAL LINK:Proyecto de la Contradicción de Criterios 272/2025 (SCJN) → https://www2.scjn.gob.mx/Juridica/Engroses/Cerrados/Publico/Proyecto/2026/02/CT272_2025.pdf

EXTERNAL LINK:concurso mercantil: guía para acreedores y proveedores → https://baraibar.com.mx/blog/concurso-mercantil-acreedores-proveedores-2026/

INTERNAL LINK:contrato mercantil o civil: criterio de la SCJN → https://baraibar.com.mx/blog/contrato-mercantil-o-civil-scjn-2026/

Frequently asked questions

Can a precautionary measure be appealed in a commercial oral trial?

No. According to the Contradiction of Criteria 272/2025, resolved by the Plenary of the SCJN in March 2026, appeals are not permitted against the determinations that grant or deny these measures, in accordance with Article 1390 Bis of the Commercial Code, which prohibits ordinary appeals in oral proceedings.

Can I file for indirect amparo without exhausting other remedies?

Yes. Since there is no ordinary remedy, the affected party can directly file for indirect amparo (constitutional protection). The Amparo Law allows for challenging acts within a trial that cause irreparable harm, and Article 17 establishes a general rule of fifteen days for filing the claim.

What are precautionary measures?

These are measures that safeguard a right while the legal proceedings are underway, such as the detention of a person or the seizure of assets. The Commercial Code regulates them starting with Article 1168. They are requested before or during the proceedings and require proof of risk and, usually, the provision of a guarantee.

What should I do if I am notified of a seizure of assets?

Immediately review the ruling, gather evidence of the damages, and calculate the fifteen-day period stipulated in Article 17 of the Amparo Law. Consider also offering a counter-guarantee to the judge. A specialized lawyer can determine whether amparo, negotiation, or both options are advisable.

Is the Court's decision now binding precedent?

The Court ordered the publication of the ruling as binding precedent pursuant to Articles 219 and 220 of the Amparo Law. Once published in the Judicial Weekly of the Federation, it becomes binding on all courts. Before citing it in a legal document, verify its registration and publication date.

Does this criterion apply to ordinary commercial trials?

Not necessarily. The criterion refers to precautionary measures issued in oral commercial proceedings, regulated by Article 1390 Bis of the Commercial Code. Different rules govern appeals in ordinary proceedings, so it is advisable to analyze the specific procedural route before choosing the means of defense.

Legal references

Commercial Code, articles 1168 et seq., 1183 and 1390 Bis (Chamber of Deputies).

Amparo Law, articles 17, 107, 219 and 220 (Chamber of Deputies).

Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation, Plenary, Contradiction of Criteria 272/2025, session of March 2026.

Judicial Weekly of the Federation (consultation of the derived jurisprudence record).

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute formal legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.